All Pro Voting
1. Lake Sivak – 130.5 Fantasy | Best Stat: 37 Points (vs Pittsburgh Chaos) | Avg: 65.25 FP per Match
Last year’s MVP has looked even sharper in 2025, sitting at a perfect 6–0 in match play. Lake’s game is pure control — precise establishments that force opponents into bad angles, coupled with knockout instincts that can crush rallies before they begin. Against Pittsburgh Chaos back on Match Day 3, he turned in a season-defining 70.75 fantasy points, piling up 37 match points, 13 knockouts, and 12 assists with zero water balls. That’s not just winning — that’s suffocating the opposition.
Lake has been the embodiment of Armada dominance, playing like a man who knows that his team’s three-year unbeaten run rests in part on his consistency. His rivalry with Erik Johnson has been one-sided, with Lake dictating every meeting between the two. If Chautauqua beats Jamestown next week, he’s the clear front-runner to repeat as MVP — but if Jamestown forces a finals absence, we may see his campaign cut short.
2. Jake Ferrari – 137.25 Fantasy | Best Stat: 31 Points (vs Doug Kirkwood Jr., Pitt) | Avg: 45.75 FP per Match
Jake came into 2025 looking to erase the disappointment of last season, and his statement came early — a historic 31-point, three-sixes performance against Doug Kirkwood Jr. of Pittsburgh, one of the most dominant 1v1 games in NSL history. He’s been the heartbeat of the Buffalo Mafia’s offense, stacking both volume and high-leverage moments across his three matches this year.
The captain’s leadership has been just as important as his numbers. Buffalo’s 3–0 start was fueled by Jake’s ability to adapt mid-match, particularly in the Chaos game where his deep-ball accuracy cracked open a tense 2v2. But while he’s a scoring machine, his 46 OOBs are the highest among top contenders — and if that trend continues, it could be the one flaw that keeps him from stealing the award.
3. Jeff Breen – 111.25 Fantasy | Best Stat: 41 Points (vs Kenzee Thornley, Pitt) | Avg: 37.08 FP per Match
The trade that sent Kade Sivak to Jamestown was a career reset for Jeff Breen. After a rough 2024 with Pittsburgh, he’s been absolutely electric for Buffalo — both in play and in team chemistry. His revenge game against Kenzee Thornley was one for the ages: 20 total points scored, and a defensive masterclass that left one of the NSL’s most respected veterans without answers.
Breen has slotted into Buffalo’s lineup as the guy who delivers the dagger. His high-intensity style has meshed perfectly with Jake Ferrari’s leadership, and his combination of knockouts and big-swing sixes gives Buffalo one of the league’s most dangerous second options. If the Mafia make the finals, Breen is in position to be a serious spoiler in Lake’s MVP repeat bid.
4. Jason Sivak – 98.75 Fantasy | Best Stat: 21.5 FP in 4v4 (vs Chaos) | Avg: 49.38 FP per Match
For three years, Jason has captained Chautauqua Armada without losing a single match — a streak that’s as much about his mentality as his mechanics. His 4v4 performance against Pittsburgh Chaos on Match Day 3 was a captain’s clinic: 21.5 fantasy points, including a six-point knockout that turned the tide and eventually the match.
Jason’s greatest weapon is his ability to pull games into his preferred rhythm, particularly in high-pressure finales. His singles win over Alex Milliner this season wasn’t just a victory — it was a statement that no matter how much history or bad blood there is, Jason controls the narrative. If Armada keep winning, his role as the constant in that dominance can’t be ignored in MVP talks.
5. Peyton Sivak – 93.75 Fantasy | Best Stat: 22 Points (vs Collin Finch, Chaos) | Avg: 46.88 FP per Match
Peyton has had one of the most varied stat lines in the league this season, with the ability to swing between a primary scorer and a setup specialist depending on match flow. His 1v1 against Collin Finch was textbook precision: three kisses, nine knockouts, and relentless scoreboard pressure that kept Chaos from mounting a comeback.
His influence extends beyond raw numbers — Peyton is a stabilizer. In the tight 4v4s, he’s the one quietly racking up assists and keeping Armada from giving up momentum. With one more match to play against Jamestown, his averages could easily spike, putting him in range of the league’s scoring leaders just in time for the finals push.
6. Erik Johnson – 133.25 Fantasy | Best Stat: 14 Knockouts (vs Jeff Nail, Pitt) | Avg: 44.42 FP per Match
Erik has been one of the most dangerous defensive forces in the NSL, leading Buffalo with 35 knockouts on the year. His duel with Jeff Nail in the Pittsburgh match was a highlight reel in itself, filled with clears that flipped the scoring table in a heartbeat.
The one black mark? His repeated losses to Lake Sivak. Whether in singles or doubles, Lake has found ways to neutralize Erik’s knockout advantage, forcing him into uncomfortable scoring attempts. If Buffalo face Armada in the finals, Erik’s MVP case may hinge on finally breaking that curse.
7. Kade Sivak – 129 Fantasy | Best Stat: 32 Knockouts (Season) | Avg: 43 FP per Match
Kade’s season started with a shock — a trade from Buffalo to Jamestown before Match Day 1. Since then, he’s been the anchor for the Ironmongers, his 32 knockouts pacing much of their defensive success. His 12 kisses also lead all MVP candidates, showing just how often he’s able to convert from mid-range into high-scoring territory.
The twist? Jamestown’s playoff hopes hinge on dropping 16 match points on Armada next week. If they pull it off, Kade gets the big-stage spotlight his season deserves. If not, his MVP run may be cut short before the league’s biggest stage.
8. Bryce Deering – 58.75 Fantasy | Best Stat: 28 Points (vs Buffalo) | Avg: 58.75 FP per Match
Bryce is the enigma of the MVP race — only one match played, but it was a monster. Against Buffalo, he was everywhere: 28 points, 11 knockouts, 5 kisses, and the kind of presence that completely shifted the Armada’s energy in singles and doubles alike.
His per-match numbers are inflated from that single performance, but he gets another crack this Saturday against Jamestown. If he comes anywhere close to repeating that debut output, his name belongs in the top half of this list, especially if Armada head into the finals still undefeated.
9. Roger Paquin – 89.75 Fantasy | Best Stat: 13 Knockouts (vs Danielle, Armada) | Avg: 29.92 FP per Match
Roger has been the steadying force in an otherwise up-and-down season for Pittsburgh Chaos. His defensive display against Alex Milliner in Buffalo’s Match Day 4 win was a thing of beauty — positioning mastery that limited one of the league’s most aggressive scorers to just three points.
While Chaos won’t be in the finals, Roger’s season has been a master class in making the most of his matchups. His combination of knockouts and assists keeps him in MVP consideration, though his lack of team success keeps his odds long.
10. Jeff Nail – 108.25 Fantasy | Best Stat: 14 Kisses (Season) | Avg: 36.08 FP per Match
Jeff’s season has been a microcosm of Pittsburgh’s year: flashes of brilliance, tempered by costly errors. His 14 kisses lead all players, a testament to his ability to execute precision scoring plays in tight spots.
He’s also been a 4v4 workhorse, regularly keeping Chaos competitive deep into matches. But with the team out of playoff contention, Jeff’s MVP hopes rest on the strength of his personal highlight reel rather than postseason heroics.